Caleb Williams vs. Drake Maye: Did Bears or Patriots draft better QB in 2024?

Key points

• Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams has been judged the better of two 2024 first-round picks, edging New England Patriots quarterback Drake Maye 4-3 in a category-by-category comparison. Williams is rated ahead on accuracy, arm strength, toughness and leadership.
• Maye is rated ahead on decision making, pocket presence and athleticism.
• The analysis weighs both players' performance across their first seasons and the early part of the 2026 season, with Williams's six fourth-quarter comebacks as a key point in his favour.